Sep. 6th, 2008 11:34 am
emony: (Elizabeth - Oh really? (E))
[personal profile] emony
I can't quite believe I'm going to say this about an episode that was written by Mallozzi and Mullie, who I generally consider to be idiots of the highest order, but .. that was really good. I loved it. To be honest, I could've done without the start and end scenes - there was no need to lever Rodney into the episode. But the stuff with the girl SG team - I wish they had a proper name, because in my head I'm calling them SG Lesbian, and that's awful. But Alison and Dusty were clearly together, for all Carson's desperate and slightly unnerving panting after the poor girl.

But how lovely it was to see Nicole de Boer again! I know she wasn't terribly popular on DS9, when she replaced Terry Farrell as Dax, but I liked her even then, and I thought she was terribly cute in this. Christina Cox was great too, as she always is, and the woman who played Dusty (who IMDB informs me is called Janina Gavankar) was good too. It was a shame that Cpt Vega had to die, because that SG team were kind of awesome. If they had their own show, I'd probably watch it.

Incidentally, Cpt Vega was in a previous episode, Search and Rescue, the first of season 5. So I would guess this SG team is very newly formed. Which would also explain why John didn't know they were a team of women - I mean, I know he can be a bit dense at times, but that's rather taking the mick.

But back to the topic is question - Cpt Vega was played by Leela Savasta, who also played Dr Esposito - she of the lovely ... smile. Secret twin sister, or have I just been watching too much Hollyoaks recently ;)

So yes, I liked the women-only SG team. And I liked the story. Okay, so there wasn't much plot to speak of. I think they did this sort of plot ("everyone running around that forest in Vancouver being chased by some sort of scary beast") better in season 3, with Phantoms, because that had some actual depth, but as far as running around being chased by unknown beasties went, I enjoyed this. The monsters were pretty scary, but there was a bit of sympathy because when you actually got up close to them, you realised they were just villagers who'd had the misfortune to get kidnapped and molested by Michael.

Mostly I think it worked because I liked the women. If I hadn't invested in wanting them to stay alive (so that people can write Dusty/Ally fic - you know you want to), I probably wouldn't have been that interested. I know Carson's fate didn't captivate me at all, and John's clearly not going to die. I liked the way Major Teldy (Christina Cox) asked John and Carson where they were, and John sort of sighed and said, "Down the well", like it was tragically cliche - which it was! But it didn't matter (to me, anyway), because my emotional investment was all with the girls.

So yes, I really liked it. Except, as I said, the opening and ending scenes. The first I suppose I could live with. It explained (sort of) why Carson was suddenly there, and set up why he and John went off with the women to explore Michael's lab. But the end scene just set my teeth on edge. Maybe it was the newly born Dusty/Ally shipper in me (LOL!), but I just hated the way Carson sort of declared that he wanted Alison as a minion to do his bidding (eugh, I just went to a bad, bad, bad place and now I feel sick), and John was like, "yep, sure, I can do that. One indentured sex slave lab assistant coming up!", like Alison gets absolutely no choice in the matter. And neither, one assumes, does her boss - either Rodney or Keller, depending on what kind of doctor she is. I would guess she's medical, given that Rodney didn't know who she was, but .. well, that doesn't necessarily mean she doesn't work with him. So yeah, that just really irritated me. I feel sort of morally obliged to write the fic myself where Alison gets a memo from Woolsey: "Congratulations STOP You're being transferred back to Earth to wash Dr Beckett's test tubes and bring him coffee STOP No more off-world adventures for you, young lady STOP A man likes you now, so it's back to Earth for you, to have babies and make pie END" and kicks up a shit fit over it.

Right. Enough of that. I'd better go and get dressed, really, as we're supposed to be going shopping today and it's almost after 12noon. Oops :)

(no subject)

Date: 2008-09-06 12:12 pm (UTC)
From: [identity profile]
I loved it too, and for the exact same reasons! I was totally emotionally invested in the women. If Dusty died, I was going to be well annoyed. She was fantastic. I didn't really see the Dusty/Alison, but I'm down with that too. :D

The end scene was atrocious. A little wrap up with the female characters would have been nice. A scene where Carson perhaps asks Alison if she would like to work with him, rather than this arrangement between men. Yes, that would have been way better.

I do hope we see them again. :)

(no subject)

Date: 2008-09-06 05:41 pm (UTC)
From: [identity profile]
Oh me too, I was worried for Dusty and I was worried for Alison and I was worried for Anne Teldy, and I was sad when Alicia Vega died - she was only on screen for about five minutes, but her death was still sad. They were great. It makes such a nice change to have decent female characters on the show! Nothing against Teyla, who's great, but she doesn't always get the best material to work with. If only they could write stories like this all the time, where people are doing something, or are in a situation, and whether those people are men or women makes absolutely no difference what so ever.

I'm probably imagining the Dusty/Alison, but there was just something in the way Dusty was when Carson was trying to chat Alison up, and that bit towards the end when they were in the corridor on their own and they just sort of looked at each other and then looked away. Heh.

I'm glad it wasn't just me on the last scene. The way Carson was saying, "oh yes, a few weeks R&R, she'll be fine" annoyed me too - one of her team mates just died, she's clearly not going to be "fine". Would Ronon, Teyla and John be fine if Rodney had just died? Would Lorne's team be fine if Parrish had just died? No. Grrr @ Carson. No cookies for you tonight, matey.

I hope we see them again too. And I hope they survive!


emony: (Default)

August 2009

161718192021 22

Most Popular Tags

Style Credit

Expand Cut Tags

No cut tags